Does tithing really work? The answer depends entirely on what you expect it to do. If you are hoping that giving will make you wealthy, Scripture never promises that. If you are asking whether giving changes something real in you, the answer is yes, and it begins in your heart.
Money is one of the last places most of us surrender. We say we love God with everything, and then when it comes to our finances, we quietly mean everything but that. God sees how we interact with Him about our money as a matter of the heart, and it defines our relationship.
So how does the practice of giving shape a heart? Four things happen.
Giving Declares That Everything You Own Belongs to God
The first thing giving does is give me the opportunity to declare that everything in my life belongs to the Lord. Psalm 24:1 says, "The earth is the Lord's and all it contains, the world and those who live in it." Everything belongs to Him. The psalmist put it right there where we can see it.
Jesus said to love the Lord your God with all of your heart, soul, mind, and strength. [Reference needed] He is saying to love God with everything. But sometimes, when it comes to money, we act like anything but that, and we set it aside. That is not everything.
I have friends who say this, and I try to say it too. A friend once loaned me his truck, and when I thanked him, he told me, "It's not my truck." I knew exactly what he meant, and he said it anyway. "It's not mine. God owns that truck, and He wanted me to share it with you this week so you could have a need met." He looks at his house the same way.
That is how my family views all our possessions, including what is in our bank account. It is His. He simply allows us to steward a portion of it, and that is what He has called us to do.
Giving Teaches You to Trust God as Your Provider
The second thing giving does is teach me to trust the Lord as my provider. Just to be clear about what that means: the Lord is my provider. Not my job, not my 401(k), not my talent and intellect, not my spouse, not my parents, and not my grandparents. They are not your provider. God the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are your provider.
When my wife and I give our tithe and offerings regularly, I am reminded that He is the great provider. This is why Paul could write in Philippians 4:19, "And my God will supply all your needs according to His riches in glory in Christ." Paul had seen throughout his life that God can and will supply every need.
So when I give, there is a prayer that accompanies it. Lord, here is me being obedient. I need You to provide my daily bread now, and I am going to trust You for that.
That is an uncomfortable place to sit, because we would prefer our finances to be solved for us all the time, so we could say we do not need God for anything financial. Complete independence is a value in our culture. But understand something: there is a beauty that comes in being reminded that all of it could be taken away, and you would still know the God who owns the cattle on a thousand hills. You would still know the God who can provide all of your needs. Everything you have could be taken away, and if you have been faithful in this way, God will show up and bring a miracle. He will show up and provide.
Watching God Provide Grows Your Faith
The third thing is that as I experience God's provision, my faith in Him increases. As I trust God with these things, I see Him come through in special ways, and my faith goes through the roof. Finances are the area where I have the most faith compared to other areas of my personal walk where I have really struggled to say, Lord, I have got to trust You with this. On the financial side, my family and I have witnessed God do what only He can do over and over again, and I believe it is a direct result of our faithfulness in our tithes and our offerings.
Let me give you a couple of examples. This first one will seem a little silly. When my wife and I got married, we were not living from paycheck to paycheck. We were broke. We had a roof over our heads, food to eat, and old used cars that got us around town. It was enough, and we were grateful for it. After we got married, we decided that she should go to school full-time and finish her degree, so we were living on a youth pastor's salary, and there wasn't much.
We started praying for vacations because we could not afford them. There was simply no money. I was tired, I needed a break, and I did not want to sit in my house for a week. So I prayed, and I think this prayer came from the Holy Spirit: God, would You please give me a friend with a condo? Please just make the introduction. I literally prayed that prayer. It may have been a selfish prayer, but we did not have the money, and the only way it would happen was if He provided it. So I prayed it. Why not?
Two weeks later, a man I had never met walked up to me at church. He had been volunteering on our security team, and he said that he and his wife had just refurbished a condo, and that God had laid it on their hearts a couple of weeks earlier to approach a pastor and give him a place to stay. You cannot tell me God is not good that way.
Then there is college. My wife and I dreamed of our kids going to a four-year school. One of our sons feels called to ministry, and the other is still figuring it out. But again, we were living check to check and not putting money away for college. Once your kids reach middle or high school, you are staring right at that bill, wondering what you are going to do. I said, well, we are going to pray. We have trusted God with our finances our whole lives, so let us keep praying.
About six months before Malachi was going to leave for college, maybe not even that long, we had decided on the school. We knew God had directed him toward it, and we were trying to figure out the finances. There was one phone call that God prompted me to make, and it seemed like a long shot. I made the call and explained the situation, and Malachi's entire college got paid for. It is actually going to be five years, because he is getting a Master of Divinity along with it, all paid for, not a dime out of our pocket. We were simply obedient, and God put it on my heart to call one person.
With my son Max, we look at it as God's provision that he scored a 35 on the ACT, because that will cover a lot of his schooling. When you reach that elite score, it opens doors that would otherwise remain closed. I cannot look at that and see coincidence. I look at that and see providence, because God is good.
This is why we read in Proverbs 3:9-10, "Honor the Lord from your wealth and from the first of all your produce. Then your barns will be filled with plenty, and your vats will overflow with new wine." What we see there is God saying, I want to do this for you. I want to bless you.
Is This the Prosperity Gospel?
No, and the difference matters. Prosperity gospel teaching says that you can essentially manipulate God into making you a millionaire if you pay your tithe and give your offerings. That is not true.
God gives a portion of wealth to people as He sees fit. That is why in the parable of the talents one person receives one talent, another receives two, and another receives five, all according to what the master saw in them. Frankly, sometimes God does not give us as much as we want because He knows we cannot handle it yet, and He is waiting for us to grow up in that area. Then you may have more at that point.
Does the Bible Condemn Wealth?
Let me make this really clear. The Bible does not condemn wealth, period. Wealth is not condemned. You are to be fruitful, multiply, prosper, master your craft and skill, and excel. That is honoring to God.
What the Bible condemns is idolatry. The problem arises when our wealth becomes a god to us, when we value it above everything else, because the love of money is the root of all kinds of evil, as 1 Timothy 6:10 puts it. Money itself is not the issue. The issue is the love of it, and the place that love takes in your heart.
Giving Breaks Money's Grip on Your Heart
That brings me to the final thing. When I give and live in this practice, it frees me from the grip that money wants to have on my heart. Money wants to have a grip on your heart. If you want to break that grip and feel free of it, give.
So, does tithing really work? It will not let you negotiate with God for a bigger bank account. What it will do is loosen money's hold on you, hand your possessions back to the One who already owns them, teach you to look to Him as your provider, and grow your faith every time you watch Him come through.
There is no shortcut to any of it. The only way to be generous and faithful in these areas is to actually do so.







